Biofuel Generations in the EU: What the RED III Feedstock Categories Mean

Biofuel Generations in the EU: What the RED III Feedstock Categories Mean

Key message: “First, second and third generation” are industry shorthand, not legal categories. Directive (EU) 2018/2001 (RED II), as amended by Directive (EU) 2023/2413 (RED III), sorts biofuel feedstocks into food and feed crops (capped, with high-ILUC-risk palm oil phased out EU-wide by 2030), Annex IX Part B (used cooking oil and animal fats categories 1 and 2, capped at 1.7%), Annex IX Part A (advanced feedstocks, which together with renewable fuels of non-biological origin carry a 5.5% sub-target for 2030), and renewable fuels of non-biological origin (RFNBOs) in their own right. The category, not the label, determines eligibility, value, certification scope and documentation. National transposition, in Germany from the 2026 compliance year, changes the economics again.

This post continues our carbon-materials and feedstocks series, moving from petroleum coke to biofuel feedstocks and the EU rules that govern them.

Biofuel generations versus EU law

In commodity trading, biofuel generations are a familiar shorthand for a feedstock’s maturity and origin. EU feedstocks are not classified by generation at all. Directive (EU) 2018/2001 (RED II), as amended by Directive (EU) 2023/2413 (RED III), defines feedstock categories by listed criteria in its articles and annexes, not by a generation number. For a trading desk, the distinction has practical consequences. A counterparty’s description of a cargo as “second-generation” says nothing by itself about its eligibility for a quota, its cap treatment, or the proof of sustainability it needs. Only the RED category does that. This article sets out the categories used in practice, the feedstocks that typically sit in each one, what the category changes for a trade, and the national rules layered on top from the 2026 compliance year.

How the industry uses “generations”

Industry usage, fairly consistent across producers, blenders and the trade press, groups feedstocks into four informal tiers. First-generation feedstocks are food and feed crops: rapeseed, soybean, palm and sunflower oils processed into FAME or HVO, and cereals or sugar crops processed into ethanol. Second-generation feedstocks are wastes and residues: used cooking oil (UCO), animal fats, tall oil, palm oil mill effluent (POME) and lignocellulosic material. Third-generation feedstocks are algae-based, still largely at pilot scale. Some commentary adds a fourth generation for engineered or synthetic routes and informally places renewable fuels of non-biological origin (RFNBOs) there. That placement is misleading: RFNBOs are produced from renewable electricity, not biomass, and are not biofuels under the RED at all.

The EU legal map

The RED, as amended, sets a 2030 transport target of a 29% renewable energy share or a 14.5% reduction in GHG intensity. Within that target, feedstocks fall into distinct categories, each with its own cap or sub-target. Food and feed crops are capped at each Member State’s 2020 share plus one percentage point, with an EU-wide maximum of 7%.

Within the crop category, high-ILUC-risk feedstocks are treated more strictly still. Palm oil is designated high-ILUC-risk under Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/807; its contribution to the targets is frozen and phased out EU-wide by 2030, with several Member States applying an earlier or additional national restriction.

Annex IX Part B covers used cooking oil and animal fats categories 1 and 2. These feedstocks are capped at 1.7% of the transport target, though a Member State may request a higher cap from the Commission.

Annex IX Part A covers a separate list of advanced feedstocks. Together with RFNBOs, Annex IX Part A feedstocks carry a sub-target of 5.5% in 2030, of which at least one percentage point must be met by RFNBOs; an interim 1% advanced-fuel target applies from 2025. Annex IX feedstocks also benefit from multipliers in energy-based accounting, generally counted twice; aviation and maritime fuels carry further multipliers, 1.2 for advanced fuels and 1.5 for RFNBOs, applied differently from one Member State to the next.

The Annex IX list itself was updated by Delegated Directive (EU) 2024/1405 of 14 March 2024 (Official Journal, 17 May 2024; in force from 6 June 2024). The update added new Part A items, including fusel oils, raw methanol from kraft pulping, cyanobacteria, and intermediate crops and crops grown on severely degraded land when used for aviation fuels, and new Part B items, including damaged crops unfit for food or feed use and intermediate crops or crops on severely degraded land when used for other transport fuels.

Feedstock map: category by category

The table below maps the feedstocks most commonly discussed in the market to their RED category, typical end product and the points a buyer or auditor will check. It is a working reference, not a substitute for the scheme documentation or national guidance that applies to a specific cargo.

FeedstockRED categoryTypical fuelVerification points
Rapeseed, soybean, sunflower oilFood and feed crop (capped)FAME, HVOLand-use criteria, GHG calculation, ILUC treatment
Palm oil and derivativesHigh-ILUC-risk crop; EU-wide phase-out by 2030; already excluded under national law in several Member States, including GermanyFAME, HVOOrigin, certification; treatment of PFAD differs by Member State, do not generalise
Cereals, sugar beet, sugar caneFood and feed crop (capped)EthanolGHG calculation; cap accounting
Used cooking oil (UCO)Annex IX Part B (1.7% cap)UCOME, HVOWaste status and point-of-origin evidence; origin diligence; UDB entry
Animal fats categories 1 and 2Annex IX Part BFAME, HVOCategory evidence under Regulation (EC) 1069/2009; rendering documentation; category 3 is not in Annex IX
POME, empty fruit bunchesAnnex IX Part AHVO, FAMEWaste status at the mill; contamination with crude palm oil; proposed national exclusion in Germany from 2027 (cabinet draft, not yet adopted)
Tall oil, crude glycerineAnnex IX Part AHVO, otherProcess-residue evidence
Straw, husks, bagasse, nutshells, lignocellulosic materialAnnex IX Part AAdvanced ethanol; HVO via pyrolysis/HTLTechnology maturity; volumes
AlgaeAnnex IX Part An/a (pilot scale)Pilot scale
2024 additions under Delegated Directive (EU) 2024/1405: fusel oils, raw kraft methanol, cyanobacteria, intermediate crops, crops on severely degraded land, damaged cropsPart A (aviation use for intermediate/degraded-land crops) or Part B (other uses; damaged crops)VariousDefinitions pending in national transposition; check scheme guidance

Two rows deserve a caution. The treatment of palm fatty acid distillate (PFAD) differs by Member State and should never be generalised from one jurisdiction to another. The Annex IX items added in 2024 are still working through national transposition, and their precise definitions should be checked against the current scheme guidance before a cargo is classified against them.

What the category changes in practice

The RED category a feedstock falls into changes several things at once, not only its eligibility for a target.

Value tier. Capped and higher-tier categories are treated differently in the market because of the caps and multipliers described above; this article does not comment on price levels.

Certification scope. ISCC EU and REDcert-EU are both Commission-recognised voluntary schemes (Commission list of recognised voluntary schemes). Each requires a proof of sustainability (PoS) issued along the chain and verified through mass balance, so a batch’s sustainability characteristics can be tracked even when it is physically mixed with other material.

Evidence at origin. For waste and residue feedstocks such as UCO, animal fats and POME, the category depends on evidence that the material was genuinely a waste or residue at the point of origin, not on a label applied later. This is what an auditor checks first.

Union Database. Transactions in biofuels and qualifying feedstocks are recorded in the Union Database for biofuels (UDB), designed to prevent the same consignment being claimed twice. Current entry obligations should be confirmed with the certification lead or the scheme’s own guidance, as they are updated from time to time.

Audit intensity. Higher-value categories, and categories with a known history of misclassification, attract closer audit attention, including on-site verification under some schemes and national rules.

Fraud patterns. Without reference to any specific case, company or country, the patterns typically described in the sector include virgin vegetable oil declared as used cooking oil, palm oil mill effluent mislabelled to obscure its composition, and animal fats assigned to a more favourable category than the rendering documentation supports. The proof of sustainability, the Union Database entry and category evidence at origin are the controls designed to catch exactly these patterns.

The national layer for 2026

EU law sets the framework; national transposition decides how it applies in practice, often with additional restrictions. Germany and the Netherlands both changed their national rules around the 2026 compliance year.

Germany

Germany’s RED III transposition, the Second Act to Further Develop the GHG Reduction Quota, was adopted by the Bundestag on 24 April 2026 and applies from the 2026 compliance year (Verbio press release, 24 April 2026; Argus, 10 December 2025, on the preceding cabinet decision; Gleiss Lutz client note). Two changes in the adopted law matter directly for feedstock suppliers. First, double counting of advanced biofuels is abolished in Germany for the 2026 compliance year: a tonne of an Annex IX Part A feedstock counts once towards the quota, not twice. Second, the sub-quota reserved for advanced biofuels rises to 9% by 2040 under the adopted law.

A further set of figures appeared in the cabinet draft that preceded the adopted law and has been reported in the trade press (Argus, November and December 2025; ENGINE, December 2025; Gleiss Lutz), but had not been confirmed against the promulgated text at the time of writing. We present these as proposed, not settled: under the cabinet draft, the crop-based cap would fall to 3% by 2030, down from 4.4%; a proposed RFNBO minimum quota would start at 0.1% in 2026 and rise to 12% by 2040; palm-oil- and POME-based fuels would be excluded from eligibility from 2027; and on-site inspections would become mandatory for production outside Germany from 2027. None of these four figures should be treated as final until checked against the Bundesgesetzblatt and the relevant BMWE or UBA publications.

Netherlands

The Netherlands published its own draft transposition in June 2025 (Argus, 24 June 2025; Vesper). As reported, the Dutch draft would end double counting for Annex IX Part B feedstocks, introduce sector-specific limits for that category, and stop crediting UCO methyl ester (UCOME) in maritime use. The draft does not fix a compliance year for these changes, and the final Dutch transposition should be checked before a counterparty’s claim about Dutch double counting is relied on.

Separately, the EU applies definitive anti-dumping measures on biodiesel imported from China, in force since 2025 (Commission Implementing Regulation, 2025). The exact duty rates and product scope are outside this article; check the current implementing regulation before relying on a specific figure.

Implications for feedstock trading

The category a feedstock sits in shapes how a trade is handled, independent of any price discussion.

Documentation discipline. Every cargo needs the category stated, the proof of sustainability matched to it, and the Union Database entry confirmed before acceptance.

Origin diligence. For waste and residue categories, origin evidence is checked before the category is accepted, not after.

Contract clauses. Sustainability warranties should be tied to the RED criteria that actually apply, with a clear point in time for PoS delivery, an audit cooperation obligation, and explicit allocation of re-classification risk.

Logistics. Mass-balance accounting depends on segregation at storage and blending sites being maintained in practice, not only on paper.

Takeaways

  • Industry “generation” labels are shorthand. Eligibility, caps and multipliers depend on the RED category, not the label.
  • Annex IX Part B (used cooking oil, animal fats categories 1 and 2) is capped at 1.7%; Annex IX Part A (advanced feedstocks) together with RFNBOs carries a 5.5% sub-target for 2030.
  • High-ILUC-risk palm oil is phased out EU-wide by 2030, with several Member States applying earlier or additional national restrictions.
  • Ask for the proof of sustainability, the Union Database entry and the category evidence at origin before accepting a feedstock’s classification.
  • From the 2026 compliance year, Germany abolishes double counting of advanced biofuels; several further German changes remain at the cabinet-draft stage and should be verified before use.

Frequently asked questions

Is UCO an advanced biofuel feedstock? No. Used cooking oil (UCO) sits in Annex IX Part B, capped at 1.7%, alongside animal fats categories 1 and 2. Annex IX Part A is a separate list of advanced feedstocks, such as tall oil, crude glycerine and lignocellulosic material.

Is palm oil banned? Not outright, but it is being phased out. Palm oil is treated as a high-ILUC-risk feedstock under Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/807; its contribution to the targets is frozen and phased out EU-wide by 2030, with some Member States applying an earlier or additional national restriction.

What is double counting and where does it still apply? Double counting lets a tonne of an eligible feedstock count twice towards a target instead of once. It is abolished in Germany for advanced biofuels from the 2026 compliance year. In the Netherlands, ending double counting is part of a draft transposition published in June 2025, not yet finalised. Always check the current rule for the specific Member State and compliance year before relying on it.

What is the Union Database? The Union Database for biofuels (UDB) is the EU’s central registry for sustainability and GHG data on biofuels, bioliquids and biomass fuels, used to track transactions and flag double claims. Current entry obligations should be confirmed with the certification lead or the scheme’s own guidance.

Learn more

Learn more: We trade ISCC EU / REDcert-certified feedstocks within our certified scope and can support documentation questions. Contact our biofuels desk.

This article is provided for general information. It does not constitute legal, regulatory, safety or commercial advice. Carriage, storage and handling decisions must be based on the applicable codes and regulations, the product safety data sheet and professional advice. Regulatory information reflects the position at the date shown; please check the current status.



Get our market commentary in your inbox.

Monthly write-ups from the Prime Elements desk — concise, on-the-record, and never templated.